I’m sure you won’t be too surprised to find out that I keep a collection of short stories in my husband’s car. If we’re stuck in traffic, I’ll pull it out and read a story aloud to him (my brother-in-law, Sweater, will be happy to know that the collection that currently lives in the car is one of Sedaris’s).
If we’re headed on a long road trip, I usually download a short-story collection onto my iPad, so I can read them aloud as he’s driving. I am not a fan of driving, and he is not a fan of reading, so it works out well.
Short-story collections are a good choice for our road trips for two reasons:
- They’re a manageable length (I can read a story aloud without getting too hoarse); and
- They’re stand-alone (If we read a couple stories on a road trip but don’t finish the book, the rest of the stories can wait until our next trip. No need for plot or character refreshers when we return to the book weeks or months later).
Our latest road-trip book was Kazuo Ishiguro’s first collection of short stories: Nocturnes: Five Stories of Music and Nightfall. As the subtitle suggests, Nocturnes is a thematic collection. The stories are linked not only by subject matter but also occasionally by a recurring character. All of the stories are about music, usually focusing on a musician (or a few musicians). But these are not upbeat stories about happy music and optimistic musicians. There is a thread of loneliness, regret, missed opportunity, and sadness that connects the five stories.
Rating: 3/5 🎼
Ishiguro is the author of Booker-Prize winner The Remains of the Day (on which this movie was based), as well as the fantastic Never Let Me Go (on which this less-than-fantastic movie was based). So, I had high hopes.
I don’t think his short stories are as strong as his full-length novels. Bryan and I both thought they were well written and objectively good but not very fulfilling. And, because the stories share so many similarities (music and sadness are present in each of the five stories, and they are all narrated by dudes with very similar voices), they were a bit repetitive and monotonous.
Summaries and ratings of the individual stories:
- “Crooner”: A guy plays in a restaurant band in a piazza in Venice. One day, he notices his hero, music legend Tony Gardner, sitting at a table in the restaurant. The restaurant-band guy introduces himself to Mr. Gardner, and Mr. Gardner hires him to help give a special (and sad) concert to Lindy, Mr. Gardner’s wife. 3/5
- “Come Rain or Come Shine”: A dude goes to visit his old friends from college, a husband and wife whose relationship is not in a happy place. He finds out soon enough that his view of them is a bit different from their views of him. He’s been invited to save their marriage in his own special way. 3.5/5 (This story was a bit funnier and far more farcical than the others; it was my favorite of the collection.)
- “Malvern Hills”: After failing to succeed in the rock world, a kid goes to live and work with his older sister and brother-in-law at their café in the countryside. One day, a Swiss couple has lunch at the restaurant, and they don’t make the best first impression on him. Later that day, he goes to his favorite spot—a bench up a hill behind the café—where he plays guitar and writes songs. He has just started playing when the Swiss couple happens to walk by and asks him to play for them. 3.5/5 (This story was a little less sad than the others; it was Bryan’s favorite of the collection.)
- “Nocturne”: A jazz musician is convinced that if he weren’t so ugly, he’d be more successful. So, he decides to get some major reconstructive surgery by the best guy in Hollywood. During his recovery, he is staying at a fancy hotel (where the rest of the plastic surgeon’s patients stay) and discovers that Tony Gardner’s wife, Lindy (reappearing here after her cameos in “Crooner”), is staying in the room next door. They become companions and nighttime adventurers. 3/5
- “Cellists”: An unemployed cellist is discovered by a self-proclaimed cello virtuoso. The virtuoso sees him perform a recital and tells him that she wants to help him reach his potential. He agrees but finds out later that she has not been completely honest with him. 3/5
Who should read it (according to Bryan): Weber (i.e., people who are really into music).
One final thought: Ishiguro’s Never Let Me Go is a book that is difficult to summarize without being spoiler-y. So, on faith, trust me when I tell you, if you haven’t read it already, you should.